Another Women’s Sport Is Letting Biological Males Compete
I’m no professional athlete, but years after my sex reassignment surgery and the near-elimination of testosterone from my system, my beginner’s tennis serve easily overpowered and dismayed the female participants when I took a junior college introductory women’s tennis course in my 40s.
The stark truth on display on that tennis court was that my
upper and lower body strength and my grip were still that of a man. No amount
of feminizing procedures could take away the strength-building effects of puberty
on my male body.
Heck, my big hands often gave me away, even though in every
other respect I appeared female.
That was a simple junior college class where the women’s
grades didn’t hinge on beating me, a transgender woman. But the stakes increase
astronomically when competition, standings, and livelihood enter the mix, as they
do in women’s sports.
A New Sport Letting in Trans ‘Women’
The latest women’s professional sport to pay homage to transgender ideology is World Long Drive golf, a sport that involves driving golf balls long distances off of tees.
A female golfer who participates recently contacted me with
concerns about the upcoming season because it will include a transgender
woman competing in the women’s division.
Australian Jamie O’Neill, born male and now identifying as female, holds a bodily advantage over all the women in World Long Drive. The stats from O’Neill’s website predict the trajectory of O’Neill’s promising career in long drive golf.
In August 2019, O’Neill’s total yardage was 280 yards. By December
2019, it was 301 yards. O’Neill’s goal is 350 yards by April 2020, which would pass
the highest championship score recorded in the Women’s Division since its
inception of 347 yards.
Without a doubt, O’Neill will crush the female competitors
in long drive golf sports. The reason is simple biology. Although now wrapped
in a female persona, O’Neill’s 43-year-old male body still provides a
dominating upper body strength and hand grip advantage.
Science Says Men Are Stronger Than Women, Even After Sex Reassignment Surgery
Men have more skeletal muscle mass, more upper-body strength, more
lower-body strength, and stronger grips than women. That’s why sports establish
separate divisions for men and women in the first place.
Tia Ghose writes in Live Science about the superior strength of men:
Men are physically stronger than women, on average. A study in the Journal of Applied Physiology found that men had an average of 26 lbs. (12 kilograms) more skeletal muscle mass than women. Women also exhibited about 40% less upper-body strength and 33% less lower-body strength, on average, the study found. …
And a 2006 study in the same journal revealed that men had much stronger grips than women—the difference was so big that 90% of the women scored lower than 95% of the men. The team also looked at highly trained female athletes who excelled at sports requiring a strong grip, such as judo or handball. Though these women did have a stronger grip compared with other women, they still performed worse than 75% of the men on this task.
Low Testosterone Doesn’t Equal Low Strength
The activists argue that transgender women don’t have a
strength advantage over women after sex reassignment surgery because their testosterone
levels drop so low. But recent scientific findings don’t support that argument.
In fact, a recent study blows it out of the water.
The 2019 study published in The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology &
Metabolism explored the effects of gender-affirming treatment on muscle
function, size, and composition during 12 months of therapy and found that transgender
women generally maintain their male muscle strength, size, and composition.
The researchers called the changes in strength “modest” and
concluded the “findings add new knowledge … which could be relevant when
evaluating the transgender eligibility rules for athletic competitions.”
Indeed, to protect the integrity of all women’s sports, it is exceedingly important to consider this finding and limit biological males’ unbridled participation in women’s sports.
Further evidence shows that a low testosterone level doesn’t
necessarily signal less strength and exercise performance, especially in those
who exercise, such as athletes. Research on men whose bodies can’t produce
testosterone (such as transgender women post-surgery) shows that even
brief exposure to exercise significantly improved muscle mass, strength,
physical function, and balance.
A 2019 study
observed male endurance athletes in intensive training and the effect on
testosterone level and performance. Many of the men saw their testosterone
levels decrease, even reaching the clinical criteria for androgen deficiency,
like transgender women do.
But interestingly, all showed an increase in
performance. The researchers reported, “[N]one of the participants displayed
any running performance decrement, in fact, the opposite occurred.”
Taken together, the evidence shows that male bodies, even with low testosterone levels, maintain male strength and their inherent, significant advantage over female bodies.
Correct This Injustice
When World Long Drive joined other professional sports to open
the women’s division to transgender women, every biologically correct woman was
diminished, demoted in effect, and became irrelevant. World Long Drive did not
stand up for women.
From weightlifting and running to boxing, cycling, and now World Long Drive golf, men who identify as women continue to infiltrate and destroy women’s sports. Meanwhile, the theories about transgender women’s strength being equivalent to women’s are being debunked.
The governing authorities over women’s sports need to
acknowledge that transgender women maintain their male strength long after
transition, and correct this injustice.